SEBI Group on Secondary Market Risk Management Exchange Traded Interest Rate Derivatives in India (2003), chaired by J. R. Varma
Download as PDF
In March 2003, the Securities and Exchange Board of India’s Group on Secondary Market Risk Management discussed the potential introduction to India of exchange-traded interest rate derivatives. It was chaired by J. R. Varma, Professor, IIM Ahmedabad. The group recognized the growing volume of derivatives trades, especially in interest rate swaps, in debt markets and identified the need for exchange-traded derivative products to improve risk management. Exchange-traded interest rate derivatives would complement the existing OTC market by enhancing transparency, reducing credit exposure, and providing centralized clearing. The group identified the potential benefits for banks, corporations, and even households in hedging interest rate risk. A roadmap for introducing products such as interest rate futures, options, and swaps on government bonds and Treasury bills was developed, with a launch date set for April 21, 2003.
The group recommended launching futures on long-term risk-free government bonds with a maturity of 10 years as well as futures on 91-day Treasury bills. Contracts would be settled in cash based on the risk-free zero-coupon yield curve. The group also advised simultaneously introducing options on these bonds and bills, with at least three strike prices. While acknowledging gaps in fixed-income analytics in India, the group stressed that an early launch with aggressive overmargining would nonetheless ensure market safety. The National Stock Exchange was tasked with refining its zero-coupon yield curve, which was central to the pricing and settlement of these contracts. The National Stock Exchange was expected to meet transparency requirements by publicly disclosing algorithms and historical data and improving yield-curve accuracy within six months.
To mitigate systemic risks, the group proposed a margining system based on Value-at-Risk, like the one used in equity derivatives. Margins would be set to cover one-day losses on 99 percent of trading days, with additional provisions for extreme market events, such as sudden interest rate shifts. The group highlighted the need for continuous research and development in term-structure dynamics, encouraging exchanges and academic institutions to collaborate on refining risk models. It also recommended that banks and financial institutions participate directly in the derivatives market, either through proprietary trading or through membership in exchanges, to improve market liquidity. Overall, the group’s recommendations laid the foundation for a structured and transparent market in interest rate derivatives, with significant improvements in risk-containment systems and product offerings.
The group’s recommendations on exchange-traded interest rate derivatives led to significant policy changes. Interest rate futures on government securities were introduced in April 2003, with banks and other financial institutions allowed to participate for hedging purposes. The zero-coupon yield curve was adopted for settlement. The Securities and Exchange Board of India implemented an overmargining strategy for initial safety based on the Value-at-Risk measure. However, the introduction of options was deferred out of recognition that the market was not ready for it.
The group's recommendations addressed the lack of transparency, credit risk exposure, and limited risk management tools in India’s debt markets by proposing the introduction of exchange-traded interest rate futures and options, adopting the zero-coupon yield curve for settlement, and implementing a Value-at-Risk-based margining system, all aimed at establishing a robust and transparent framework for managing interest rate risk.